How do I get leads for annuities?

The most effective way to get leads for annuities is through education-first content marketing. Create short educational videos explaining annuity concepts, target pre-retirement demographics (ages 45-65), and use a branded lead system where prospects consume 10-15 of your videos before booking an appointment. This builds trust and familiarity, which is critical for annuity sales.

Where can I buy leads for annuities?

You can buy annuity leads from vendors like Lead Concepts, CABoom Leads, or InsuranceLeads.com for $250-$500+ per lead. However, these are typically cold, shared leads with low conversion rates. A better approach is building your own branded lead system or using a done-for-you service that provides exclusive, warm appointments with prospects who already know and trust you.

What makes a good lead for annuities?

A good annuity lead is someone between ages 45-65, approaching retirement, has accumulated savings ($75,000+ household income), and is concerned about outliving their money. More importantly, they've engaged with your educational content multiple times, understand annuity basics, and trust you as an advisor before the first conversation. This pre-qualification dramatically increases close rates.

How much should I pay for annuity leads?

Traditional annuity lead vendors charge $250-$500+ per lead, but these cold leads often have 10% or lower contact rates. Instead of buying leads, invest in building your own acquisition system through courses like S.C.A.L.E. ($1,497) or use a done-for-you branded leads service ($833-$2,667/month) that provides exclusive, warm appointments with much higher conversion rates.

Leads for Annuities: The 2025 Guide to Finding Qualified Prospects Without Wasting $250 Per Name

MADLeadFlow

Published: November 25, 2025

11 min read

The $250 Problem: Why Buying Leads for Annuities Is a Broken Model

Leads for annuities are potential customers interested in purchasing fixed, variable, or indexed annuity products. The industry standard is purchasing these leads from vendors for $250-$500+ per name. This model fails for annuity sales because annuities require education, trust, and relationship-building—none of which come with a cold lead list.

Here's the math that exposes the problem: If you're spending $250 per lead and only 10% answer the phone, you've spent $2,500 to have 10 conversations. If 20% of those conversations result in appointments, you've spent $2,500 for two meetings. If one closes at a 10% commission on a $100,000 annuity, you've made $1,000. You've lost $1,500 before factoring in your time, overhead, and the emotional toll of constant rejection from people who don't know you.

[IMAGE BLOCK] Description: Infographic showing the math of buying cold annuity leads - $250 per lead, 10% contact rate, 20% appointment rate, resulting in a net loss of $1,500 per closed sale Alt Text: Annuity lead cost breakdown infographic showing $250 per lead results in $1,500 loss per closed sale (https://xizjskkzgykceegylutx.supabase.co/storage/v1/object/public/MADLeadFlow%20Website/Knowledge%20base%20Articles/Gemini_Generated_Image_1fpsjp1fpsjp1fps.png) Caption: The real cost of buying cold annuity leads: Even when you close a sale, you're losing money before accounting for your time and overhead.

Why Annuity Leads Are Different: Education Before Transaction

Annuity sales require a fundamentally different approach than other insurance products. A term life insurance sale can happen in one call. An annuity sale requires multiple touchpoints because you're asking someone to move significant retirement savings. They need to understand:

How annuities work and the different types (fixed, variable, indexed)
Surrender charges and liquidity constraints
Tax implications and retirement income planning
How annuities fit into their overall retirement strategy

This education process can't happen in a cold call to someone who doesn't know you. It requires trust. And trust requires familiarity. This is where the traditional lead-buying model breaks down completely.

[IMAGE BLOCK] Description: Side-by-side comparison showing cold lead vs. branded lead journey - cold lead goes straight to sales call (low trust), branded lead goes through 10-15 educational touchpoints before call (high trust) Alt Text: Comparison diagram of cold annuity leads versus branded annuity leads showing trust building process (https://xizjskkzgykceegylutx.supabase.co/storage/v1/object/public/MADLeadFlow%20Website/Knowledge%20base%20Articles/Gemini_Generated_Image_7ts5st7ts5st7ts5.png) Caption: The branded lead system builds trust through education before the first conversation, resulting in 3-5x higher close rates than cold leads.

The Branded Lead System: How to Generate Leads for Annuities That Actually Convert

A branded lead for annuities isn't just someone who saw your ad. It's someone who has consumed 10-15 pieces of your educational content before you ever speak. They've watched videos explaining:

"What is a fixed annuity and when does it make sense?"
"The 5 biggest annuity mistakes retirees make"
"How to protect your retirement from market volatility"
"Fixed vs. Variable Annuities: Which is Right for You?"

By the time they book an appointment, they already trust you as an educator. They're not a cold prospect; they're a warm lead who's pre-qualified themselves by engaging with your content. This is the unfair advantage that turns annuity sales from a numbers game into a relationship business.

Why This Matters for Annuity Products

Unlike term life insurance, annuities are long-term commitments with significant capital requirements. Prospects need multiple touchpoints to build confidence. A branded lead system provides these touchpoints automatically, at scale, before you invest your time in a sales conversation.

Building Your Annuity Lead Generation System

Step 1: Create Education-First Content

Your content strategy should focus on teaching, not selling. Use our Free Agent Ad Scripts as a starting point, but adapt them specifically for annuity education:

Content Pillars:

Annuity Basics: Simple explanations of how different annuity types work
Retirement Planning: How annuities fit into broader retirement strategies
Case Studies: Real examples (with permission) of how annuities solved specific problems
Common Mistakes: What to avoid when considering annuities
Market Updates: How current economic conditions affect annuity strategies

Each piece of content should answer a specific question your ideal client has. Film these as 15-30 second videos. You don't need a studio—a smartphone and good lighting are enough.

[IMAGE BLOCK] Description: Visual showing the 5 content pillars for annuity education - Annuity Basics, Retirement Planning, Case Studies, Common Mistakes, and Market Updates, arranged in a circular or connected diagram Alt Text: Five content pillars for annuity lead generation education strategy (https://xizjskkzgykceegylutx.supabase.co/storage/v1/object/public/MADLeadFlow%20Website/Knowledge%20base%20Articles/Gemini_Generated_Image_dj50madj50madj50.png) Caption: These five content pillars form the foundation of an effective annuity education strategy that builds trust and positions you as an expert.

Step 2: Target the Right Demographics with Precision

While vendors sell you broad demographic lists, you can target with surgical precision:

Age: 45-65 (pre-retirement and early retirement)
Income: $75,000+ household income
Interests: Retirement planning, financial security, investment education, estate planning
Behaviors: Engaged with financial content, visited retirement planning websites, downloaded retirement guides
Life Events: Recently retired, approaching retirement, inherited money, received pension payout

Platforms like Facebook and LinkedIn allow you to layer these targeting options, ensuring your ad spend reaches people who are actually in the market for annuity products.

[IMAGE BLOCK] Description: Visual representation of precise demographic targeting for annuity leads - showing age 45-65, income $75K+, interests, behaviors, and life events as overlapping filters Alt Text: Demographic targeting filters for annuity lead generation showing age, income, interests, and behaviors (https://xizjskkzgykceegylutx.supabase.co/storage/v1/object/public/MADLeadFlow%20Website/Knowledge%20base%20Articles/Gemini_Generated_Image_sonpe7sonpe7sonp.png) Caption: Precise demographic targeting ensures your ad spend reaches qualified annuity prospects instead of wasting money on unqualified leads.

Step 3: Build a Conversion Funnel That Educates

Your landing page shouldn't just capture contact information. It should continue the education process:

The Offer: "Get Your Free Retirement Income Analysis" or "Download: The Complete Guide to Fixed vs. Variable Annuities"
The Value: Provide actual, actionable information in exchange for their contact info
The Automation: Use CRM automation to send a sequence of educational emails that build trust over 7-14 days before asking for an appointment

This approach positions you as an advisor, not a salesperson. By the time they book a call, they're already sold on your expertise.

Step 4: Nurture with Multi-Touch Sequences

Annuity prospects need time to process information. Your automated sequence should include:

Day 1: Welcome email with the resource they requested
Day 3: Educational content about annuity types and benefits
Day 5: Case study or success story (with permission)
Day 7: Invitation to book a complimentary consultation
Day 10: Follow-up with additional value (market update, tax tip, etc.)
Day 14: Final invitation with social proof and urgency

This multi-touch approach respects the buyer's journey while keeping you top-of-mind.

[IMAGE BLOCK] Description: Timeline visualization showing the 14-day email nurture sequence for annuity prospects - Day 1 welcome, Day 3 education, Day 5 case study, Day 7 invitation, Day 10 follow-up, Day 14 final invitation Alt Text: 14-day email nurture sequence timeline for annuity lead conversion (https://xizjskkzgykceegylutx.supabase.co/storage/v1/object/public/MADLeadFlow%20Website/Knowledge%20base%20Articles/Gemini_Generated_Image_acw1pracw1pracw1.png) Caption: A strategic 14-day nurture sequence builds trust gradually, respecting the annuity buyer's longer decision-making process.

The Two Paths Forward: Build or Buy (The Right Way)

You have two options to escape the annuity lead-buying trap:

Path 1: Build Your Own System

This requires investment in learning but gives you a permanent asset. You'll master:

Content creation and video production
Paid advertising on Facebook, LinkedIn, and Google
Funnel construction and automation
Email and SMS sequences
Retargeting and lookalike audiences

For agents serious about learning to run your own ads, our S.C.A.L.E. course provides the complete blueprint for building annuity lead generation systems that work long-term.

Path 2: Done-For-You Branded Leads

If you need annuity appointments now and have capital to invest, a done-for-you service builds and manages the entire system. You receive exclusive, warm appointments with prospects who already know and trust you. This is the fastest path to ROI for established agents who want to scale without learning the technical side.

Both paths are superior to buying cold leads because they build assets that compound over time. Every dollar spent on your own system or a branded leads service builds your brand and creates long-term value.

[IMAGE BLOCK] Description: Comparison chart showing "Buy Cold Leads" (renting, no brand building, high cost per acquisition) vs. "Build Your System" (owning, brand building, lower cost over time) vs. "Done-For-You Service" (owning, brand building, immediate results) Alt Text: Comparison of three annuity lead generation strategies: buying cold leads, building your system, and done-for-you service (https://xizjskkzgykceegylutx.supabase.co/storage/v1/object/public/MADLeadFlow%20Website/Knowledge%20base%20Articles/Gemini_Generated_Image_9ypgm79ypgm79ypg.png) Caption: The two paths to owning your annuity lead generation both build long-term value, unlike buying cold leads which is pure expense with no asset creation.

What the SERP Results Miss: The Real Cost of Cold Leads

The top search results for "leads for annuities" are dominated by vendors selling lead lists. They don't tell you:

Shared vs. Exclusive: Most vendors sell the same leads to multiple agents, meaning you're competing with 3-5 other agents for the same prospect
Contact Rates: Industry average is 10-15% contact rate on cold leads, meaning 85-90% of your investment is wasted
Conversion Math: Even if you contact someone, they don't know you, trust you, or understand annuities. Your close rate will be 5-10% at best
No Brand Building: Every dollar spent on cold leads is money that doesn't build your brand or create long-term value

The vendors aren't in the business of helping you succeed; they're in the business of selling data. Every $250 you spend on a cold lead is money that could be invested in building your own acquisition system.

The Bottom Line: Stop Renting, Start Owning

The annuity lead vendors dominating the SERP are selling you a broken model. They're not in the business of helping you succeed; they're in the business of selling data. Every $250 you spend on a cold lead is money that could be invested in building your own acquisition system.

Annuity sales require trust, education, and relationship-building. These can't be bought in a lead list. They must be built through consistent, valuable content that positions you as the expert your prospects need.

For more information on how we generate branded leads specifically for annuity and retirement planning professionals, explore our services. The future of annuity sales belongs to agents who own their lead generation, not those who rent it.

Sources: